Understanding the Process of Contesting a Trust in Indiana
As the beneficiary of a trust, you are entitled to benefit from the assets held by the trust. You are dependent, however, on the Trustee to distribute those assets to you. The Trustee, in turn, must abide by the terms of the trust as created by the Grantor (creator) of the trust. What happens if you believe those terms are unfair, illegal, impossible, or that the trust agreement is otherwise problematic? Can you contest the trust? The Simple answer is “yes,” a trust can be contested. Contesting a trust in Indiana, however, is a complex legal process that requires careful consideration of various factors, including grounds for contesting the trust, procedural requirements, and strategic considerations. The Indianapolis attorneys at Frank & Kraft help you understand the process of contesting a trust in Indiana.
Trust Basics
A trust agreement is a legal instrument that is often used to manage assets and estates. A trust is created by a Grantor who appoints a Trustee to administer the trust for the benefit of a beneficiary or beneficiaries. Disputes may arise, however, regarding the validity or administration of a trust, leading to contests in court. Contesting a trust in Indiana involves a complex legal process governed by state laws and regulations and should not be attempted without first consulting an experienced trust administration attorney. It helps, however, to gain a basic understanding of what is involved in contesting a trust if you are contemplating a trust contest.
Grounds for Contesting a Trust in Indiana
Contrary to popular belief, a trust cannot be contested simply because a beneficiary or heir is unhappy about the terms of the trust agreement or because they were left out of the trust entirely. Instead, you must have legal grounds on which the trust could be declared invalid to initiate a trust contest in Indiana. Grounds that could be used include:
- Lack of Capacity: One of the primary grounds for contesting a trust in Indiana is the assertion that the Grantor lacked the mental capacity to create or modify the trust. Indiana law requires that individuals creating a trust must be of sound mind and understanding. If it can be demonstrated that the Grantor was not mentally competent at the time of establishing the trust, the trust agreement may be declared invalid.
- Undue Influence: Contesting a trust on grounds of undue influence involves alleging that the Grantor was coerced or manipulated by another individual to create or modify the trust in a manner contrary to their true intentions. Proving undue influence requires evidence showing that the Grantor’s decision-making was overridden by the influence of another party.
- Fraud or Duress: Trusts created under fraudulent circumstances or through coercion may be contested in Indiana courts. If there is evidence of deceit, misrepresentation, or duress in the formation of the trust, it may be deemed invalid. Contestants must present clear and convincing evidence to substantiate claims of fraud or duress.
- Improper Execution: Indiana law specifies certain requirements for the valid execution of trusts, including proper signing and witnessing procedures. If a trust document fails to meet these legal formalities, it may be subject to contestation on grounds of improper execution. Common errors include lack of proper signatures or witnesses, ambiguity in language, or failure to comply with statutory requirements.
- Mistake: Contesting a trust based on mistake involves demonstrating that the Grantor made an unintentional error in the creation or terms of the trust. This could include clerical errors, typographical mistakes, or misunderstandings regarding the trust’s provisions. Contestants must provide evidence of the mistake and its impact on the trust’s validity.
What Is Involved in Contesting a Trust in Indiana?
The process of contesting a trust typically begins with filing a petition with the appropriate court in Indiana. The petition should outline the grounds for contestation and provide relevant evidence supporting the contestant’s claims. Navigating the legal complexities involved in filing a petition to contest a trust is best accomplished with the advice and guidance of an experienced trust administration attorney. After you file the petition, the court will issue a summons to notify all interested parties, including the Trustee, beneficiaries, and other relevant individuals, of the contestation proceedings. Serving proper notice ensures that all parties have an opportunity to participate in the legal proceedings and present their arguments. The discovery phase allows parties involved in the trust contestation to exchange relevant information and evidence through methods such as depositions, interrogatories, and requests for production of documents. Mediation may be used to resolve the dispute outside of court. If the matter cannot be resolved through mediation or settlement, the case may proceed to trial.
Are You Contemplating Contesting a Trust in Indiana?
For more information, please join us for an upcoming FREE seminar. If you have additional questions or concerns about contesting a trust in Indiana, contact the experienced Indianapolis trust administration attorneys at Frank & Kraft by calling (317) 684-1100 to schedule an appointment.
The post Understanding the Process of Contesting a Trust in Indiana appeared first on Frank & Kraft, Attorneys at Law.
