State
Trials & Litigation
State rep displays middle finger during online court hearing, leading to show-cause orders
September 5, 2024, 3:20 pm CDT
Florida State Rep. Randy Fine, who appeared to be displaying his middle finger and making other gestures during an online court appearance, is facing an Oct. 1 contempt hearing. (Screenshots via Judge Scott Blaue’s show-cause order)
A Florida state representative who appeared to be displaying his middle finger and making other gestures during an online court appearance is facing an Oct. 1 contempt hearing.
Florida State Rep. Randy Fine, a Republican, was ordered to show cause why he should not be held in contempt for alleged “offensive conduct” during the Aug. 19 hearing, report Florida Today and WESH.
Judge Scott Blaue of Brevard County, Florida, issued the show-cause order Tuesday while issuing a second order to Fine’s lawyer, Ryan Christopher Rodems.
Blaue ordered Rodems to show cause why he shouldn’t be held in contempt for failing to advise or admonish his client against such conduct.
Blaue’s show-cause orders include screenshots of Fine touching his face with his middle finger extended and making an “L” with his hand, which according to WESH, is a gesture interpreted to mean “loser.” The orders also include an email sent to Blaue’s judicial assistant by Fine’s political opponent, Chuck Sheridan.
“I am watching the hearing,” Sheridan wrote, and Fine is making concerning hand gestures, as well as “mouthing vulgar words,” such as “F- – – you a- -hole.”
Blaue also attached screenshots of a meeting chat in which viewers asked someone to please tell Fine to “stop the obscene gestures.”
Blaue’s orders cite prior Florida cases defining contempt as “an act tending to embarrass, hinder or obstruct the court in the administration of justice or to lessen the court’s authority or dignity.”
The Aug. 19 court appearance had been scheduled on Microsoft Teams, according to an Aug. 15 order by Blaue attached to the show-cause orders.
“The court requires video appearance and proper court attire,” the Aug. 15 order said.
The show-cause orders also direct Fine and Rodems to explain why they failed to comply with terms of the Aug. 15 order.
Fine was wearing a T-shirt for his state Senate campaign during the hearing. Judge Blaue tossed the case late last month.
According to Florida Today, Burns and Fine “have a long-running public feud going back to 2020, when Burns represented Fine’s opponent in a particularly vicious primary race.”
Rodems did not immediately respond to the ABA Journal’s email request for comment.
Fine told WESH that he was told that the hearing would not be recorded. He also questioned why the judge took so long to raise the issue.
“If I was doing things he didn’t like, why did he wait two weeks to do anything about it?” Fine told the broadcast station.
He acknowledged wearing a campaign shirt but said “that’s what happens when you’re having a hearing at 3:45 p.m. the day before an election.”
Fine denied making obscene gestures in a lengthy statement to Florida Today.
In the statement, Fine referenced a motion in which Blaue published Fine’s home address before Fine received death threats.
“Judge Blaue’s behavior in this case has been nothing short of appalling. Fine Or he does–and is supporting Trump-style lawfare in our community,” Fine said in the statement.
“Now, Blaue wants to have a hearing based on alleged behavior two weeks ago–using photographs Blaue himself said must not exist (due to courtroom restrictions on recording), and that if it actually happened and Blaue was paying attention, he would have seen and handled in real time,” Fine wrote. “He doesn’t seem to realize that the entire premise of the hearing is that he doesn’t know what is happening in front of his face in his own courtroom.”
Hat tip to the Florida Bar’s Daily News Summary.
